Yes Ron, that's the question, which one was first?

On the "Pal Joey"-LP-version, Frank is off-key on the first "That's" (why the lady), and the trumpet note that preceeds that word is off-key as well. Both notes, trumpet and vocal, are on key in the "Rodgers & Hart"-LP-version.

However, on the Rodgers & Hart-LP version, Frank cracks up reather heavily on the word "lady" in the second of the final three repeats of the line "That's why the lady", while on the Pal Joey version, the second "lady" is done in tune.

Bernhard.